A large number of Indian professionals have settled in the United States. When an NRI marriage starts to break down, the first confusion is where to fight the case: in the US or in India? The answer matters, because the two systems work very differently. This article compares them on the six points that come up most in our NRI consultations.
1. Grounds for divorce: no-fault versus fault-based
United States. Every US state allows some form of no-fault divorce. One spouse can usually end the marriage by saying it has broken down irretrievably, and the other spouse's consent is not needed. Some states add a waiting or separation period.
India. A divorce by mutual consent is available (Section 13B of the Hindu Marriage Act). If the other spouse does not agree, you must prove a legal ground such as cruelty, desertion or adultery. See our page on contested divorce.
2. Restitution of conjugal rights
India. Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act lets a spouse ask the court to direct the other to resume living together when they have left without a good reason. If the couple does not resume cohabitation for one year after the decree, that can become a ground for divorce.
United States. There is no such remedy. A US court will not order a person to live with a spouse. Read more about the Indian remedy on our restitution of conjugal rights page.
3. Dividing property
United States. Property acquired during the marriage, including retirement accounts such as a 401(k), is generally treated as shared. Nine states, including California, follow community property rules with an equal split. Most other states follow "equitable distribution", which means a fair split that is not always 50-50.
India. There is no general system of matrimonial property. As a rule, property belongs to the person whose name is on the title. A wife's streedhan remains hers. Courts decide maintenance by looking at income and means, and do not divide everything equally. Section 27 of the Hindu Marriage Act allows the court to deal with property given to the couple jointly at the time of marriage.
4. Maintenance and spousal support
United States. Spousal support is gender neutral. A higher-earning wife can be ordered to pay her husband. Child support follows state formulas based on both parents' income.
India. Sections 24 and 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act allow either spouse to seek maintenance, and Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (earlier Section 125 CrPC) covers wives, children and parents. In practice, the claims are made far more often by wives, and courts focus on financial security for the dependent spouse and children. See maintenance and alimony.
5. Child custody
United States. Courts commonly order joint legal custody, so both parents share decisions on schooling and health. Taking a child abroad without the other parent's consent can be treated as abduction.
India. Courts apply the welfare of the child. One parent usually has main custody, and the other has visitation rights. For Hindus, a child under five is ordinarily with the mother. See child custody.
6. Domestic violence
United States. Police act quickly after a complaint and can issue restraining orders. For visa holders this can affect immigration status, so take advice before reacting.
India. The Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 gives protection, residence and monetary relief, and there are separate criminal provisions on cruelty and dowry harassment. See domestic violence and Section 498A.
The most important warning for NRIs: foreign divorce decrees
Many NRIs get a divorce from a US court, often without the other spouse taking part, and assume the matter is over. In India it may not be. Section 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure says a foreign judgment is not conclusive if, among other things, it was not given by a court of competent jurisdiction, was not decided on the merits, or was obtained in breach of Indian law or without proper notice.
For matrimonial cases, the Supreme Court in Y. Narasimha Rao v. Y. Venkata Lakshmi (1991) held that a foreign decree is recognised in India only if the foreign court had jurisdiction under the law governing the marriage, the grounds are ones the Indian law recognises, and the spouse had a fair chance to defend. A spouse who simply does not turn up has not necessarily agreed to the foreign court's authority.
If a foreign decree is not recognised, the marriage may still exist in the eyes of Indian law. A second marriage could then expose a person to a bigamy complaint (Section 82 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita) and to maintenance claims.
What to do
- Do not rely on a foreign decree in India without having it reviewed by an Indian lawyer.
- If your spouse has filed abroad, respond promptly and take advice in both countries.
- Think about where each of you can file, because the choice of court can change the result.
- Keep records of marriage, residence, money and children in both countries.
If you or a family member is in an NRI divorce, custody or property dispute, speak to us early. See our NRI divorce lawyer page, call 86260 20635 or send an enquiry.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Please consult a lawyer about your specific situation.