More couples now marry across borders, own assets in more than one country and think about money before the wedding. That is why prenuptial and postnuptial agreements come up so often in our NRI consultations. The surprise for many clients is how differently the United States and India treat them. This article explains the difference in plain terms.
What are prenups and postnups?
- A prenuptial agreement (prenup) is a written contract signed before marriage. It sets out how assets, debts, property and spousal support will be handled if the marriage ends by divorce or death.
- A postnuptial agreement (postnup) does the same job but is signed after the wedding. It is often used after an inheritance, the start of a business, or a big change in finances.
The US position
In the United States, prenups and postnups are widely used and generally enforced, provided there was full financial disclosure, no pressure and no unfairness so extreme that a court will not uphold it. The details vary from state to state, but the starting point is that adults are free to arrange their own finances in advance.
The Indian position: generally not binding
In India, a prenup is generally not legally binding or automatically enforceable. No statute bans it, but several features of Indian law work against it.
1. Marriage is not treated as a pure contract
- Hindu law (Hindu Marriage Act, 1955): marriage is treated as a sacred union, not a commercial deal, so a contract that sets the terms of its own ending does not fit comfortably within the law.
- Muslim law: marriage is a civil contract (the Nikahnama), and certain pre-marital terms such as the amount of mehr or conditions on maintenance can be recognised and enforced, as long as they do not conflict with the law.
- Special Marriage Act, 1954: there is no provision for attaching a prenup to a marriage registered under the Act.
2. Public policy
Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 makes an agreement void if the court treats it as opposed to public policy. Indian courts have traditionally taken the view that a contract planning for a future divorce undermines the stability of marriage.
3. You cannot contract out of statutory rights
Even a spouse who signs a waiver cannot give up rights that the law gives to protect them. A prenup cannot override:
- the right to maintenance under Section 144 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (earlier Section 125 CrPC);
- the right to a shared household under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005;
- the right to interim and permanent maintenance under Sections 24 and 25 of the Hindu Marriage Act, which the court decides on the parties' means at the time.
If an agreement leaves one spouse with almost nothing, an Indian court is unlikely to enforce that part of it.
Are they useless in India, then?
Not entirely. Courts here have increasingly treated a properly prepared pre-marital agreement or Memorandum of Understanding as evidence, even though it is not binding. It can help to show:
- What each person owned when they entered the marriage, which helps if wealth is exaggerated later.
- Intent and understanding. It records the couple's shared thinking about money at the time, which a judge may weigh when assessing a settlement as fair.
Settlement terms agreed during a divorce are different. In a mutual consent divorce, the agreed terms on maintenance, property and custody are placed before the court and recorded in the decree, which makes them enforceable. Read more on our mutual consent divorce page.
The Goa exception
Goa is the one part of India where prenuptial agreements are fully recognised. Goa continued to use the Portuguese Civil Code of 1867 after liberation, and the Goa, Daman and Diu Administration Act, 1962 allowed those laws to continue.
- The default rule is comunhão de bens, a "communion of assets". On marriage, the couple's assets, whether owned before or acquired after the wedding, merge into one estate, and each spouse holds a half share. Neither can sell major property without the other's consent.
- A prenup lets a couple opt out and choose another regime, such as complete separation of assets, or separation of pre-marital assets with only post-marriage acquisitions shared equally.
- Because the code itself offers this choice, a Goa prenup is treated as a choice about how to manage finances during marriage, not as a plan for divorce.
Two strict conditions apply. The agreement must be made by public deed, before a civil registrar or notary, before the marriage is registered. And once the marriage takes place, the chosen regime cannot be changed. There are no postnups in Goa.
What this means for you
- If you live in the US and may have assets or a case in India, take advice in both countries before signing anything.
- A prenup is still worth having for clarity and evidence, but do not assume it will decide everything in an Indian court.
- Do not use an agreement to take away basic rights such as maintenance or the right to a home. That part will not hold.
- If you are marrying in or moving to Goa, the choice of regime needs to be made before the wedding.
For advice on your own situation, call 86260 20635 or send an enquiry. You can also read about our NRI divorce work.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Please consult a lawyer about your specific situation.